Understanding Indian Permanent Establishment (PE) Risk for Foreign Companies (2025)

For foreign companies eyeing the vast opportunities in the Indian market, understanding the concept of Permanent Establishment (PE) is paramount. It’s one of the most critical and often complex areas in international taxation. If a foreign company is deemed to have a PE in India, a significant portion of its business profits attributable to that PE can become taxable in India.

The Indian tax authorities have significantly increased their scrutiny of PE issues, especially with the evolving digital economy and global efforts to combat base erosion and profit shifting (BEPS). Navigating this intricate landscape requires proactive planning and expert guidance. As a leading CA firm in Mumbai, CA Sweta Makwana & Associates specializes in international taxation, helping foreign entities mitigate their PE risks in India.

What is a Permanent Establishment (PE)?

A Permanent Establishment (PE) is essentially a fixed place of business through which the business of an enterprise is wholly or partly carried on. This definition is primarily derived from Article 5 of most Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAAs) signed by India and is also referenced in Section 92F(iiia) of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Purpose of PE: The concept of PE determines which country has the right to tax the business profits of a foreign company. Under most DTAAs, the business profits of an enterprise of one country are taxable only in that country, unless the enterprise carries on business in the other country through a PE situated therein. If a PE exists, only the profits attributable to that PE can be taxed in the source country (India, in this case).

Indian Tax Implications if a PE is Triggered:

The foreign company’s business profits attributable to the PE become taxable in India.
The profits are typically taxed at India’s domestic corporate tax rates.
The PE must obtain a Permanent Account Number (PAN) in India, maintain proper books of accounts, get them audited, and file an income tax return in India.
The PE also becomes subject to Indian withholding tax (TDS) provisions on various payments.

Types of Permanent Establishments in India

DTAAs and Indian domestic law broadly define various types of PEs:

1. Fixed Place PE (Basic PE)

This is the most common type and refers to a specific physical location.

Requirements: It generally requires a fixed location, a certain degree of permanence (e.g., typically a minimum of 6 months, as per DTAAs), and the actual carrying on of core business activities through it.
Examples: A branch office, a factory, a workshop, a place of management, a sales office, a drilling rig, or even a construction site (if it lasts beyond the DTAA specified period, usually 6 months).
Exemptions (Preparatory or Auxiliary Activities): Most DTAAs exempt activities that are merely preparatory or auxiliary in nature from constituting a PE. Examples include:
- Use of facilities solely for storage or display of goods.
- Maintenance of a stock of goods solely for storage or display.
- Maintenance of a stock of goods solely for processing by another enterprise.
- Maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for purchasing goods or collecting information.
- Maintenance of a fixed place of business solely for advertising, supplying information, or scientific research.

2. Agency PE (Dependent Agent PE – DAPE)

This type of PE arises when a foreign company has an agent in India who acts on its behalf and has certain authorities or engages in specific activities.

Triggers: The agent habitually exercises authority to conclude contracts in India on behalf of the foreign company, or habitually maintains a stock of goods from which they regularly deliver on behalf of the foreign company.
Distinction: An independent agent (acting in the ordinary course of their business and at arm’s length) generally does not create a PE. The key is whether the agent acts ‘independently’ or ‘dependently’ on the foreign company.

3. Service PE

Many of India’s DTAAs include a ‘Service PE’ clause.

Triggers: This arises when a foreign company furnishes services, including consultancy services, through its employees or other personnel in India for a specified duration within a given period (e.g., typically exceeding 90 days or 183 days within any 12-month period, depending on the specific DTAA).
Common Scenario: On-site consultants, technical support teams, or project managers providing services in India for extended periods.

4. Construction/Installation PE

Triggers: A construction, installation, or assembly project, or supervisory activities in connection therewith, lasting beyond a certain period (usually 6 months, as per DTAAs).

5. Significant Economic Presence (SEP) – India’s Domestic Law

While not a traditional ‘PE’ under DTAAs, India introduced the concept of Significant Economic Presence (SEP) in its domestic Income Tax Act (Section 9) in 2018. This is a crucial concept for foreign companies in the digital realm.

Purpose: To tax digital businesses even without physical presence.
Triggers: Transaction with any person in India involving goods, services, or property exceeding a prescribed value (e.g., INR 2 crore per financial year) OR systematic and continuous soliciting of business activities or engaging in interaction with a prescribed number of users in India (e.g., 3 lakh users).
Note: The applicability of SEP to DTAA-covered entities is currently subject to DTAA provisions. However, SEP serves as a strong signal of India’s intent to tax digital businesses.

Common Triggers for PE Risk in India

Foreign companies should be aware of these common activities that can inadvertently trigger a PE:

Employee Presence: Having employees or representatives regularly visiting or residing in India for core business activities (beyond merely preparatory/auxiliary functions like market research).
Dedicated Office Space: Leasing or having a fixed place (even a co-working space) ‘at their disposal’ in India.
Sales & Marketing Activities: Sales personnel habitually negotiating or concluding contracts in India, or signing off on deliveries.
Inventory & Warehousing: Maintaining a stock of goods in India for direct delivery to customers, rather than just for storage or display.
Service Delivery: Providing technical, professional, or consulting services on-site in India for extended periods.
Digital Operations: Significant user interaction, data collection, or revenue generation from India through online platforms, even without physical presence (SEP risk).
Dependent Agents: Relying heavily on agents who essentially act as extensions of the foreign company rather than truly independent entities.

Implications of PE Formation

If a PE is established, the consequences can be significant:

Indian Tax Liability: Business profits attributable to the PE become taxable in India, potentially leading to higher tax outlays.
Attribution of Profits: Determining the profits attributable to the PE is a complex exercise, often requiring transfer pricing principles (Arm’s Length Principle) and potentially leading to disputes.
Increased Compliance Burden: The foreign company must comply with all Indian tax regulations applicable to a domestic entity, including obtaining a PAN, maintaining books of accounts, getting an audit done, and filing regular income tax returns.
Withholding Tax Issues: Non-compliance with Indian TDS provisions could lead to disallowances or additional tax liabilities.
Reputational Risk: PE disputes can be lengthy, costly, and damage the company’s reputation.

Mitigating PE Risk in India

Proactive planning is key to managing and mitigating PE risk:

Structured Operating Models: Carefully design your operational model, considering entry strategies like liaison offices, project offices, or subsidiaries, based on the nature and extent of planned activities.
Clear Segregation of Activities: Ensure that activities carried out by employees or agents in India are genuinely preparatory or auxiliary in nature, if the intent is to avoid a PE.
Independent Agent Agreements: Ensure that any agent operating in India is truly independent and operating at arm’s length. Review contractual terms meticulously.
Duration Monitoring: Rigorously track the physical presence of personnel in India to avoid triggering service or construction PEs.
Contractual Review: All agreements with Indian parties (e.g., employment contracts, service agreements, distribution agreements) should be drafted carefully to minimize PE exposure.
Centralized Decision-Making: Ensure core business decisions, contract conclusions, and significant approvals are made outside India.
Leveraging DTAAs: Understand the specific PE clauses and exceptions in the DTAA between India and your company’s country of residence.
Advance Rulings: For complex or ambiguous situations, consider seeking an Advance Ruling from the Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) to obtain certainty regarding PE status.
Regular Review: Periodically review your operations in India to ensure they remain compliant with current PE rules and DTAA provisions.

The Indispensable Role of a CA / International Tax Advisor

Navigating the complexities of Indian PE rules and their interplay with DTAAs requires specialized expertise. CA Sweta Makwana & Associates provides comprehensive international tax services:

PE Risk Assessment: We conduct thorough assessments of your planned or existing operations in India to identify potential PE risks.
Entry Strategy Advisory: We advise on the most tax-efficient and compliant entry strategies into the Indian market.
Contract Review & Drafting: We review and help draft contracts to minimize inadvertent PE exposure.
Compliance Services: We assist with obtaining PAN, maintaining books of accounts, statutory audits, and timely filing of income tax returns and TDS compliances for your Indian operations.
Profit Attribution Analysis: We help in determining profits attributable to a PE, if one is established, using appropriate transfer pricing methodologies.
Dispute Resolution: We represent foreign companies before Indian tax authorities during assessments or in PE-related tax disputes.

Conclusion

For foreign companies operating or planning to operate in India, understanding and managing Indian Permanent Establishment (PE) risk is non-negotiable. The landscape is dynamic, with increased focus from tax authorities and the evolution of digital business models. Proactive planning, meticulous adherence to DTAA provisions, and continuous expert guidance are essential to navigate this complex area successfully. This prevents unforeseen tax liabilities and ensures a sustainable presence in one of the world’s fastest-growing economies.

Considering establishing or expanding your presence in India? For expert international tax advisory and PE risk mitigation strategies, get in touch with CA Sweta Makwana & Associates today. We empower your global business ventures with local compliance expertise.

Explore our International Taxation Services for comprehensive support in cross-border tax matters.